Thursday, March 13, 2014

A Twit petition


For those of my readers who are not ‘down’ with Twitter, this is a pointless read. Please check out Sabir Nazar’s excellent cartoon instead
Freedom of speech has to be the most ridiculous idea since people said to Noah, “Nah, I think we’ll be fine without your boat.” It is that piece of statutory (s)crap which has caused the most wars, conflicts, professional wrestling matches and husband-wife separations than any other freedom enjoyed by man. Except maybe the freedom of conjugate.
But even the beghairat liberal in me gets outraged when certain individuals take their right to say what they want, a little too far. If one has any preoccupation with the social media, one knows that one is referring exclusively and vociferously to the entity known only as @SaroorIjaz. Never before has malice, wit, venom and goose-stepping neo-Grammar Nazism been so perfectly encompassed in one Twitter handle. But what started as a seemingly-harmless joke, quickly degenerated into an unbridled verbal sword fighting with soiled diapers being hurled in all directions. You had to be there. It was hilarious. And outrageous.
I will hold my horses for the next two paragraphs to bring you all up to speed. @SaroorIjaz is a brand-spanking-new Twitter account which has resisted all attempts to label it ‘a parody account’ of one Saroop Ijaz, an erudite legal eagle who exercises his pen for the Express Tribune. And what a lovely pen it is. Indeed, Saroop is a master wordsmith and has the power to turn dribble into poetry, all the while writing in prosaic prose. He is also an extremely affable chap, praised by all and sundry who have allegedly met with him. While one has never had the privilege, one can safely report that said lawyer is a ‘Good Man’.
That, unfortunately, is more than one can say for the fictitious @SaroorIjaz. Saroop himself has no Twitter account, nor does he have (I am told) the inclination to own one in the near future. However, the imposter uses Saroop’s photograph and his persona as an Express Tribune columnist and has the bejeezuz fooled out of nearly everyone on Twitter. Like Engineer Majorly Profound before him, @SaroorIjaz has gone viral on Twitter. Well, sort of.
You see, the best way to be popular on Twitter is to have Twitter fights. This was my first lesson in the 140-character world, courtesy a musician friend of mine. Then, it was made clear to me by an ubertroll, that trolling (which is another word for foreplay, really) was what two people did to each other when one of them wanted to take the other out on a date. Obviously, he was trolling too. But then I was set right by another writer, who pointed out that ticking off the right people was the wrong thing to do. The right people being assorted haseenas or hawt wimmens. One young intellectual taught me the importance of having something intelligent to say all the time, while a certain former newspaper editor showed me that it was possible to be precise, funny and nice at the same time.
However, @SaroorIjaz has interfered with that utopia. He has singled out many of the above individuals and has chosen to make himself a marked man by marking said individuals and making them the focus of his grammatically-perfect and verbose attacks. This, obviously, means war. For too long has anonymity been the bane of the existence of many social media users. Too plentiful are cases of users being bullied, battered and made to wet their self-esteem by excessively vicious cyber-bullies. Mostly of the feminist variety. It is high time that we put into practice what @SenRehmanMalik said to us at #SOCMM12 in Karachi. It is time. Ladies and gentlemen. To fry some eggs. Some very bad eggs. Out with the andas and in with the hawt wimmens with gratuitously doctored-and-photoshopped display pictures.
There are simply too many excuses for being a gratuitous potty mouth. But when you turn that mouth onto others, things get complicated. And bloody. I am currently in process of enlisting the services of a good lawyer to take the right dishonorable @SaroorIjaz to court, via Twit petition. RT this if you agree.

Where's the fun?


Safe, politically correct and ideologically sound humour is like a vodka martini, without the vodka
Sometimes I think we need an excuse to bring our blood to a boil. If it’s not the conversion of unsuspecting minorities to the folds of Islam on national television, it’s the amount of indiscriminate load shedding that plagues the upper and central parts of the Punjab. Incidents where guardians of the public good let loose their ‘good faith’ on certain ruffians who had the gall to let morsels pass their throats during the day also invite the ire of the liberal guardians of our sanity. In fact, even the new blue of the Olympic hockey field drew many frowns and scowls. Change.org now hosts a petition on the subject and the International Olympic Committee is considering reverting to the traditional green of Olympics past, in the face of mounting pressure from social media hacks.
I must admit that I had little or no inspiration to write a column this week and only did so on the insistence of my editor. To add to my woes, the power crisis chose this very day to make a house call and left the family and me without electricity for about nine hours. At the time of going to press, power had only returned to half the house i.e., the bathroom and the outhouse. The bedrooms and the airconditioners were still, inexplicably, without power. The UPS that powered our erstwhile fans sputtered to a dead halt sometime around iftaar. It seems that many such appliances will be meeting their makers tomorrow, unless some enterprising bijliwallah decides to keep his shop open until after iftaar, which, if you know your bijliwallah well enough, is a statistical impossibility.
Ramadan makes life difficult in a variety of ways. It is the month that you are forced to confront that demon within you rather than the ones God created to distract us. Unfortunately for us, our demons are far more advanced than anything John Milton could ever imagine. Beelzebub would shudder in his shoes and Mephistopheles would run for cover if he were introduced to some of our own, more domesticated devils. For instance, Mathira, the “kuchee kuchee” gal of late night TV, has come out with yet another “bold and baring” photo shoot. While I am a huge (literally) fan of the girl from Garden, I must confess that her timing is a little off. She now risks being slotted in with Veena Malik as a wannabe controversy queen and may stand to lose her mojo.
The Naked Tyrants, a bunch of losers from Lahore with a camera and a lot of toilet humour, have come out with a Ramadan-special edition video, dedicated to hormonal men everywhere. The aptly entitled ‘TotaQuest’ is not the latest edition of Final Fantasy, but is a gripping satire on the amount of frustration endemic in our society as a whole. But my friends from the feminist side of the divide would have you believe that these boys are doing nothing more than promoting misogyny and are, in fact, doing womankind a great disservice. Frankly, I think they’re goddamn hilarious.
But this is a troubling tendency. As of late, people have been becoming all too sensitive. Whether it is rape threats (real or imagined), personal attacks or litigation based on things that happen online, tolerance for others’ viewpoints is significantly decreasing. Where one was once ‘innocent until proven guilty’, now the innocent need to prove their credentials, lest they be branded heretics. Those that do not conform to the general (liberal) narrative are cast out of social discourse and venom is the language that is currently being used to fill in the pages of history (at least online).
Last week, Feisal Naqvi wrote a brilliant vindication of freedom of speech on the social media. I feel I can add nothing to the discourse, except to say “PEOPLE, CALM THE F*** DOWN!” It is depressing that means of communication that were once touted as the next best thing for building bridges are now becoming divisive tools in the hands of amateurs and trolls. The ability to laugh at oneself as well as others is fast becoming eroded from the public sphere and it looks like the bubble of social media may yet burst. I for one would be very sad to see that happen, because it would leave me no place to test whether a joke falls flat or is received with some belligerence. Any humorous attempt that is mocked and frowned upon can and should be considered usable material. Safe, politically correct and ideologically sound humor is like a vodka martini, without the vodka: it’s good for you, but then, where’s the fun in it?

Morality plays


The problem with morality is that it is subjective. If we come up with a yardstick for what is moral and what isn’t, TV channels would have a hard time selling us such garbage
My father is not a man given to outrage. At the age of 65, just a few months older than the country itself, he leads a retired, unassuming life. He likes his tea without sugar, one-ball-foursomes on the golf course and enjoys primetime talk shows to the fullest. After years of watching his favourite anchors and politicians get beaten to a pulp on live TV, he is a channel surfer par excellence. So imagine my surprise when last night, over iftar, dad comes down from his room in a huff and starts venting like a man who has seen too many corrupt officers promoted ahead of those who rightfully deserved the reward.
The cause of his chagrin? Those happy-go-lucky talk show hosts now masquerading as Ramzan experts. Messrs Liaquat, Masood, Maya, Sanam and (if the seths see it fit to let her show air) Veena. The point of having such well-recognised and highly (sic!) respected TV personalities hosting sehr and iftar shows, ostensibly, is to build a personal connection between the channels and their viewers. This is why Aamir Liaquat, that most revered of televangelists, is hosting a Neelam Ghar-esque quiz show as part of his Ramzan transmission. It is reminiscent of the legendary show not because Mr Liaquat bears any resemblance to the great Tariq Aziz, but because the amount of advertiser branding in every given frame of said show was matched only by the genius of Neelam Ghar.
Victims of the recent violence that has wracked Karachi are also invited to the (and I use the adjective loosely) good doctor’s show. Once there, they are treated like Wasu was in Shehzad Roy’s last music video i.e., pushed to the background while Herr Doktor takes centre-stage and asks the million dollar question, “Who is responsible for these tragic deaths?” The answer is almost always a unanimous chorus of “the government of the day”. Fortunately for the purposes of the monologue that is to follow, no representatives of the government or the law-enforcement agencies are on hand to refute, rebut or explain the allegations levelled against them. This is possible because Dr Liaquat does not pretend to be a journalist and is actually merely doing a public service by interfering in the realm of journalism by allowing anyone and everyone to share the screen with him.
The icing on the cake is even sweeter. As the time to make or break one’s fast nears, the spirit of Nigella Lawson enters Dr Liaquat and he becomes possessed by the djinn of fine cuisine. The culinary experience is so thorough and so convincing that one is forced to soil themselves with drool in anticipation of the feast that is to come. And it’s not like the good doctor will eat all that yummy food himself. In fact, he has scores of ‘ordinary people’ (read friends of the production staff) who are more than willing to share a dastarkhwan and the Geo TV screen with the makhan-monger of yesteryear.
Sanam Baloch, the Lux Style Award-winning star of SAMAA TV’s morning show and Maya Khan’s replacement, has also broken out her black mourning dress and can be seen strutting her stuff on set in full make-up as she talks to wailing widows and other marginalised peoples, all the while, maintaining her impeccable hairdo and making sure that her crocodile tears do not mess with her mascara.
The terrific (read terrible) twosome of Dr Shahid Masood and Maya Khan are back to their old tricks and making Ramzan intolerable for all sane people on ARY News. While the old timer from the ‘End of Times’ is being his usually self, the dater-hater Maya has donned the mantle which, up until now, was only the domain of the Roman Catholic church. Papal pardons used to be a thing of ridicule, but now Maya is handing out pardons to all and sundry who confess their sins. The saucier your sin, the greater the value of the pardon. Of course, you have to be shameless enough to own up to said sins on national television. Otherwise, it just doesn’t work.
The problem with morality is that it is subjective. If only we could come up with some sort of objective yardstick for what passes off as moral and what is decidedly immoral, TV channels would have a hard time selling us the garbage that they are currently airing in the name of Ramzan. After all, the good people over at the Express Media Group pulled Veena Malik’s show due to a furore over whether such a sinner can be allowed to host a show which calls upon people to cast out their demons. Maybe it’s time other took a leaf out of their books and sent all these nauseating talk show charlatans to Sahir Lodhi’s show for a good old-fashioned exorcism. My father will be pleased.

Vilification, MBBS


There are those who believe that all the media does is manipulate what people think. Honestly, we don’t have the time
It is very easy for the media to manipulate the way people think. There are those that will have you believe this is all the media does, ever. But frankly, we never have time from editing footage, subbing stories and designing layouts to actually plot world domination through careful, subliminal messaging. It would be too arduous and painstaking, especially for people who have to navigate deadlines like Indiana Jones navigates traps in ancient Mayan temples. It’s a madhouse.
So imagine my delight when I hear people vilifying journalists and anchors for taking sides and telling only one side of the striking doctors’ story. It’s the perfect set up. Take an issue that can be broadly termed ‘public interest’; simmer for a few days in the fire of sensationalism and misreporting; bring to a violent boil by petitioning judiciary and government to intervene; and of course, sit back and enjoy. Of course that’s what people think goes on in the newsrooms and editorial meetings of major media houses. And of course, they’re not being quite accurate.
What is the doctors’ complaint with the media so far? That it has been blatantly anti-doctor for the duration of this strike? That it has not called attention to the high-handedness of the Punjab government and has instead focused solely on crucifying the young doctors? That it has painted the Young Doctors’ Association (YDA) in a negative light? Well, while it pains me to say this, what else did you expect from the populist mainstream media?
You see, media perception of any issue, i.e. the information that it relays and the footage that it broadcasts, is shaped by two things; what the reporters tell it and what feedback it receives from miscellaneous sources. Reporters, especially health reporters, are usually a sly lot. They have to be, because they deal with hundreds of different people (most of them doctors) on a daily basis. To fool a health reporter is usually not an easy task. But it can be done. So while one emergency department may have shut down and others remained open, the reporter can go to that one closed ward, shoot footage of wailing women and sobbing children, and air it with the assertion that all (or most) emergency departments in the city, are shut down.
A reporter would do this for two reasons: either he’s been told to do it from ‘high up above’; or he’s trying to press the doctors to give him a scoop or settling a petty vendetta (revenge for not giving him a scoop). In any event, this will cause doctors to reconsider and open up to said reporter, who will have a comprehensive piece in the next day’s paper, or a 90-second news story in the 9PM bulletin. There are very few reporters who actually go to the trouble of checking out hospitals themselves. I know some reporters like this; a few are even good friends and sound professionals. One can immediately tell from the way they talk that they are balancing their opinions subconsciously. A good reporter will always, even when giving you his opinion, tell you at least two sides of any story.
These good reporters have this to report: the doctors’ strike has been called off, but there is still dissent among the messiahs’ ranks. There are grumblings of defiance from certain groups who, it is said, were even contemplating contempt of court. But sanity prevailed and cooler heads thought that would be going too far. As of Monday evening, out-patient departments and emergency services are (by and large) up and running in most of Lahore’s major hospitals.
The new doctors that were ‘hired’ by the Punjab government are also an interesting phenomenon. These did not magically appear out of thin air, but were really post-graduate medical trainees who were already working at these hospitals when the YDA went on strike. They were the ones manning the fort in the doctors’ absence and may be safely considered heroes in their own right. And it is ironic that the strike should have inadvertently achieved one of its demands, as the regularisation of these trainees constitutes a major chunk of the YDA charter of demands. That’s a twist of fate if there ever was one.
But on the government side, all is not rosy. Already heavily in debt, Punjab cannot afford to accede to all the doctors’ demands. So they will try to stall. This has not worked out in the past either and the government has swept things under the rug by trying to divert attention to media-friendly epidemics, such as dengue. But not enough resources are available to revamp or substantially improve the healthcare services offered in the province. Overdraft is not the answer. We need a solution, fast. Before more messiahs become fallen angels. And more of the fallen become false martyrs.

In sickness/health


For their pains, the doctors figure they should be better remunerated and have more izzat than assorted government bureaucrats
It is yet another scorching day in Short-Term-Memory-Loss-istan. The mainstream media is taking sides, again. The social media hacks are up in arms, again. In the scorching heat of the summer sun, millions of ‘mango people’ are being sunburnt, dehydrated and carted off to the morgue for want of basic medical attention. Therefore, the ‘young’ doctors are out on strike. Again. The ‘old’ doctors, meanwhile, are supposedly sipping cognac in their dinner jackets, holding their pinkys to their mouths and sniggering wildly as they watch the mayhem unfold onscreen. If this were an Oliver Stone movie, it would sweep the Razzies. Unfortunately, the story comes from the most infamous of the Stans; which is why it must be underplayed and glossed over. But consider some facts.
Since its inception in 2008, the Young Doctors Association has sent its members on strike a total of eight times. In the 2011-2012 period alone, this is the third such strike. Obviously, doctors play by baseball rules and are now ‘sitting out’ the remainder of the time that this impasse continues. Sunday’s closure of the emergency ward at Mayo Hospital is another indication that the doctors are bent on seeing this through to the bitter end. Much like the US government, these doctors also consider all casualties along the way are ‘acceptable collateral damage’, a small price to pay to achieve their long term strategic goals. In fact, the blood of these casualties is not on the hands of the professionals at all: it is on the manic fangs of the monster that is the Punjab government. Those extremist-hugging right-wing sons of guns must be to blame for this; because they usually are the most convenient of scapegoats. What with their ridiculous sloganeering of ‘good governance’.
Then there is the question of their ‘demands’. In the words of ‘Striking Doctors for Dummies’, the YDA has two principal demands: more pay and better employment benefits. While this is an oversimplification, it is not too far from the truth. Doctors, after being allowed to unionise, have now realised that their pay and service structures are quite unfair to those of them (read all of them) who have put themselves through the extensive (and expensive) trouble of medical school. For many, this is roughly the equivalent of two tours of duty in Vietnam, Afghanistan or Mozambique. For their pains, the doctors figure, they should be better remunerated and have more izzat among the ranks of lowly secretaries and other assorted government bureaucrats. While their demands for more pay were met last year, when the Punjab government agreed to raise doctors’ salaries by 40 percent in the fiscal year 2011-2012 and by another 60 percent in the fiscal year that began last Sunday. That’s about a 100 percent raise from March of 2011. That’s about a 100 percent increase in a sixteen-month period.
Unfortunately, that is not all they want. The question of izzat still remains unresolved. Doctors want to be free of the shackles of the Basic Pay Scale system. Either that, or they want that all Medical Officers in government hospitals (which is like being a lecturer at a public sector university, an entry-level position for young graduates) to be BPS-18 employees. Ostensibly so they can attest their friends’ documents and help forge visa applications. Also, they want that postgraduate trainees be paid the same as aforementioned Medical Officers, mostly because they do all the work while the Medical Officer goofs off. And ‘supervises’: these trainees must always be supervised. No, really. But on top of that, they want that the ‘Health Professional Allowance’ (money they get for just having taken the trouble to become doctors) be made equivalent to each doctor’s basic pay.
On the face of it, these demands look quite benign. Acceptable, even. In fact, if this were a first world country, there would be no need to have a strike in the first place, because all these demands would’ve been accepted immediately. Sounds legit, no? Well, it’s not. The world over, doctors and healthcare professionals such as homeopaths and chiropractors grumble and complain about bad pay and unreasonable work hours, not to mention exceptional stress at the workplace. But unlike other places, here, the doctors have an obstinate and broke Punjab government to deal with. And what the Punjab government can’t pay for, it will put in the hands of a committee. Which is exactly what has happened to these demands.
Being a doctor isn’t easy by any stretch of the imagination. Especially when you have the Hippocratic Oath to honour and a family to feed. But somehow, oaths and professional commitments take a backseat when it comes to the size of one’s wallet and ego. While the demands of the Young Doctors may be reasonable, the means they are employing to drive their point home are not kosher, to say the least. While I do not support nor justify state highhandedness against medical professionals, I do believe that violence and incitement to violence begets a violent response. Doctors, as a profession, are not to blame. But it is incumbent upon their ‘leadership’ to be true to the cause and focus on finding a ‘political’ solution to the impasse. The closure of emergency wards is an underhanded tactic, one which cannot be endorsed, no matter what the circumstances.
It’s time the Khadim-e-Aala woke up and smelt the coffee. He needs a health minister like an addict needs his next fix; right now. The government of Punjab needs to understand the gravity of the situation and come up with a comprehensive plan that will solve this issue in the long run. And the doctors need to be less stubborn and more sympathetic to the plight of their fellow beings. Have we learnt nothing from the last time, or the time before that, or the one before that?
But I digress. Welcome to Short-Term-Memory-Loss-istan

Hard times


The new mass media seldom has time to verify and ample time to vilify
If you’re looking for a new career path, look no further than the pages of this newspaper. If you are talented, have the analytical skills necessary to tell the difference between your nose and a humming bird, and can follow orders, no matter how inane; a career in journalism is exactly what the doctor ordered. Being on prescription medication is an added qualification, but not a prerequisite.
Like the many over-the-top real estate ads that adorn 9PM bulletins on our ever abundant news channels – which would have you believe that there has never been a better time to invest in real estate in Dadu and Hyderabad – there can be no such illusions about the state of the media in Pakistan. While viewers are distracted by the high-sounding news and scandals breaking on TV screens day in and day out, media houses lay people off at least two days a week; cough up salaries for staff such as reporters, camerapersons, editors, technical, production and support staff every third month and buy themselves new talk show hosts almost every other fortnight.
Journalists too have become fickle creatures. With things getting tighter by the day, media professionals with more developed survival instincts have begun hopping from leaf to leaf, like veritable frogs in a pond full of pitfalls and crocodiles. One false step could land them in the drink, or worse. Horse-trading may have been banned from parliament, but it has reared its financially attractive head in the media sector and has taken everything by storm. This applies more to talk show hosts and their lackeys more than it does to seasoned professionals, but that is inconsequential. What matters is that the glorified mouthpieces of media magnates, spewing forth propaganda badly disguised as ‘public interest journalism’, take home a fat salary.
But spare a thought for the hardworking men and women who make these anchors and tycoons what they are: you can’t, can you? This is because you don’t know them, can’t empathise with them. On a recent trip to Karachi, I had the chance of visiting some of my old friends at their workplaces. At Geo News, I met with the old gang from the ill-fated channel Geo English. Despite all the bhal safai and bad blood, a good two dozen strong were still there, toiling away in an organisation that is a mere shadow of its former glory. While the toys and the new studio are quite impressive, behind all the glitter is the sad fact that it is not a blood-sweat-and-tears news organisation anymore, but a well-oiled machine. The chaos of the newsrooms of old was gone and replaced by an uneasy calm. There was no yelling over the phones, no last minute instructions to the anchor or any harried phone calls from the transmission department asking to cut to commercials. Everything was running smooth. A little too smooth.
SAMAA was no different. Everyone on the programming floor was quite pleased to still be there. I saw several familiar faces, seated in the exact same seats that I left them in all those years ago. I saw many new faces, met many old friends who had now migrated to the channel from other, less green pastures. The consensus here was that the news business is no longer about news anymore. Programming has gone from original, factual content to dramatised and exaggerated soap operas. There is now a great demand for gossip, hearsay and scandal. The new mass media seldom has time to verify and ample time to vilify.
I met with a lot of senior people as well, all of whom had the same, bleak story to tell. It is hard times for the industry. Newspapers and TV channels are spending (or losing) more money than they are making. This does not include political injections from satisfied parties that go into the pockets of those in power. Each organisation, as an organisation, is crumbling. And being seths, media tycoons are now opting to create their own workforce rather than hiring a skilled one. These fresh recruits are then burdened with responsibilities that range from camera work to hosting primetime talk shows.
In such dire circumstances, we can ill-afford skeletons in our closet. It would be best if media houses steered clear of controversy and not became a party to all that is going on in the country, lest they be dragged into the mud themselves. Wait, what?

Romanticising the rail


Somewhere during the 25-hour ride from Lahore to Karachi I vowed to make my friend, who had said “Shalimar Express is a good option”, eat his words with a knife and fork

There’s nothing quite like a train ride. If you’ve ever travelled on a train as a child, you will know of the fantastical wonders these carriages offer for the young, imaginative mind. The clack-clackity-clack of the wheels on the track provide a primitive drumbeat for all sorts of imaginary adventures; the many compartments yield sources of entertainment and amusement. The joy of finding other children to play with, the sights and sounds out the window, the rush of air as you open the door and stick your head out of the moving train: these are all pleasures unimaginable to those who have never experienced rail journeys.
As a child, I had more than my fair share of trains. My father was a civil servant in the employ of the Pakistan Railways. Much like military kids, railway children were also shuttled around a lot as their parents find new postings in remote locations. In my case, I was born in Faisalabad, pre-schooled in Lahore and Sukkur, carted around in a house-on-wheels through Quetta, Peshawar, Karachi and Rawalpindi before dad got permanently posted to headquarters in Lahore. I was nine when the moving stopped, and I hated being a landlubber. Still do. Sort of.
The proverbial house-on-wheels, or saloons, as they are referred to by those in-the-know; are unique, condo-style accommodations. A kitchen, quarters for the cook and the stenographer, a living area, two bedrooms and a lavatory comprise this phenomenon that was my surrogate home for the better half of the first nine years of my life. Through the windows of these accommodations, I was introduced to Pakistan. Needless to say, I promptly fell in love with the vast, undulating plains and lush crop fields of the Punjab; the dusty expanses of Sindh, the barren nothingness of Balochistan and the rolling mountainous landscape of the Frontier province. It was an education and a playground. My sense of Pakistani geography was honed by the stops on the Peshawar to Karachi line, and places such as the domed station building at Samosatta, the mammoth junction at Khanewal, the limestone ridges of Rohri, or even the blackened earth of Aab-e-Gum (on the line to Quetta) are still etched onto my memory. It was a dream machine, which (especially after watching the third Back To The Future movie) would be my ship through imagined adventures through space and time. Being a child with an overactive imagination and a penchant for getting my way, I set up my first trainset-within-a-train at age 5. My mother still proudly displays photos every time we have company over.
Through the years, the frequency of my travels via rail decreased. With the discovery of the motor car and the acquisition of the driving license, I had acquired yet another vehicle for my dreams (albeit somewhat different and definitely less complex than the ones I had entertained aboard any train). But the nostalgia and the longing for train rides did not leave me. Finally, at age 28, after nearly fifteen years of travelling solely by air or by road, I decided to take the train from Lahore to Karachi. It was to be the culmination of a childhood well-spent: I wanted to bring closure to the visions of my youth.
Having worked as a journalist for over eight years, I was no stranger to the state of the modern railway system in Pakistan. Having seen ministers such as bumbling Bilour and catastrophic Qazi come and go, I knew that the Pakistan Railways of today was a far, far cry from the days of yore. Still, I persevered with my plans and through the ‘kindness’ of some friends, bought my ticket for the Shalimar Express. It was going to be a journey I would not soon forget.
For the average traveller seeking to reach the port city from my hometown of Lahore, there are several options. The aptly-named Awami Express is the people’s choice: there are no air-conditioned compartments or dining car. But this train carries most of Pakistan’s migrant/labour class to and fro between the two largest cities in the country. The Karachi Express is the second option: here, the air conditioning is occasional and optional at the same time. This means that while one would normally not see an AC bogey attached to the train; when one is mistakenly included, the chances of the air-con working adequately are about the same as the chances of you finding lasting relationships on matrimonial websites. The Karachi Express also takes a pretty long-winded route to Karachi, stopping at every station between the two-destinations, no matter how small. Each stop is usually longer than 30 minutes, ostensibly to facilitate senior citizens who take longer than usual to board/disembark from the labyrinthine compartments of economy class.
The Shalimar Express used to be the staple choice for travellers wishing to spend 18 (sic!) hours in the ‘lap of luxury’, especially since its privatization. The Business Train, the crowning achievement of private enterprise, is the closest we in Pakistan will ever come to a ‘bullet train’, seeing as this is the only train one expects will depart and arrive at its destination relatively on time. However, anecdotal evidence suggests that even this modern marvel is seldom on time. But what it lacks in punctuality, it makes up for in terms of comfort and style, so passengers here usually forgive any tardiness.
So it was no surprise that I asked for a ticket on the Business Train. But a friend of mine, also a journalist, who covers the Railways beat for another, more widely circulated newspaper, recommended with great aplomb that I opt for the Shalimar, as it was the more economical option. He also insisted that it was, “just as good”. But somewhere along the way, as the Shalimar Express trundled along the Lahore-Karachi line, I vowed to make him eat his words with a knife and fork.
You see, I took my well-meaning friend’s advice in good faith and boarded the Shalimar at 5:45 AM. The train left the station at a reasonable 6:05AM, but from then, everything went downhill. My ticket, having been purchased by said friend, turned out to be valid for the Lower-AC section, as opposed to the Parlour Car. This was a blow to my well-fed and elitist ego, but I persevered. Then, I was forced to ‘purchase’ a pillow that would be my companion for the rest of the journey, for a measly Rs 20. This did not suit me at all, because I would’ve paid at least five times that sum to get my hands on a more comfortable seat, but I was provided no such option.
But about three hours in, I realised that this train was not quite the ‘non-stop’ that I had imagined it to be, since it went up to Faisalabad before starting its southward descent towards Karachi. Hardly an hour outside said city, the engine broke down and the train was held up for three hours in the blistering Punjab summer sun. I was indifferent to this, having slept through most of the delay. Once we set off again, the air-conditioning promptly decided to turn itself off. This was quite the setback, and upon inquiry, I discovered that the air-con was ‘out of gas and would not be fixed until the next major junction.
However, I was not too worried, because I knew that Khanewal would be along in a matter of hours. But when the clock struck three and I looked out the window and realized that we were still slowly making our way towards said stop, I began to worry. Khanewal took another hour to arrive, and it was there we were told that the AC technicians would meet us at Rohri. Already, there were murmurings of a coup among my co-passengers and the women, having divested their children of all clothing, began to fling curses at the railways top brass, their families and sundry others. At 6PM, 12 hours after we had left Lahore, we were still wandering the tracks in Punjab. Rahim Yar Khan passed at 8PM and we managed to reach Rohri at 11PM. By this time, the power in all AC-compartments had been severed by a cruel twist of fate and the passengers were up in arms. Desperate to quell the disquiet, the private staff of the train arranged for the AC to be fixed and fired up the power supply. This shut people up for all of twenty minutes, because that was how long both things ran without fail.
At exactly 12:01AM (the day after we left Lahore), the power and the air-conditioning failed and plunged the 90-odd passengers in my compartment into a darkness blacker than anything Joseph Conrad could have imagined. Tired of this turn of events, I left my seat to investigate and returned ten minutes later to discover that my friend in misery, the Rs 20-pillow, had been purloined. This turn of events shattered me completely, especially because the man on the berth above mine insisted on keeping it in the ‘sleep’ position, even when he was merely masticating on some gutka, which he would discard in the space between the berth and the wall. This refuse would trickle down to my headboard, but my trusty pillow would shield me from the nastiness. With that gone, all I could do was sweat it out and inhale greenhouse gases from my berth. After about an hour of that, when I could take it no longer, I decided to go sit in the doorway, something that should be illegal. But because of the extenuating circumstances, the staff allowed me to plant myself squarely in the doorway for about four hours. This helped me reflect on the journey and also terrified the living daylights out of me when the train would stop, inexplicably, in the middle of nowhere, for what seemed like several different eternities. That this was daku-country was making things even worse for my paranoia.
At the 23 hour mark, at 5:30AM, the electricity and the air-con suddenly roared to life and within a couple of hours, we were passing Malir Cantt. I stopped to take stock of the situation and discovered that due to excessive sweat, my seat was now a veritable kiddie pool and smelt like a bull on heat. Each time I walked, dust would emerge from the fabric of my pants and shirt and distribute itself over my shoes. A trip to the loo revealed that mud had accumulated on my domed head in such massive quantities that I looked positively negroid.
To be honest, I cannot believe a happier time than when the train finally pulled into the Cantonment Station in Karachi. Delivered from my trials, I walked triumphantly over the mango crates that were strewn across the walkways of the compartment, scrambled over the lines of porters jostling for position and stepped out into the Karachi sea breeze. I was disgusting, but to me, it felt like the Arctic wind.
I’m sure that after reading this whiny rant, you must think that I would have sworn off trains for the rest of my life. Unfortunately, I am what they call a Pakistani, i.e. I deliberately seek out misery for sport. Therefore, I am pleased to announce that in three days time, I shall be seeing the Pakistan Railways ticketing officer in Karachi to buy my ticket back. If you’re reading this, ticketing officer, be afraid. Be very afraid.